Trading with the Nazis

- Episode 10-

Death Camp tattoos were IBM numbers

Death Camp tattoos were IBM numbers
6 March 2024
All History Café links
Final episode in NEW SERIES Trading with the Nazis

 

[photo] Rick's bar in the 1942 movie Casablanca directed by Michael Curtiz, starring Humphrey Bogart as Rick, Ingrid Bergman as Ilsa and Arthur 'Dooley' Wilson as Sam

Play it again Sam?

American companies routinely stayed in contact with their German subsidiaries throughout the war. They deny it, of course, and many of the documents are … er … now missing. But the truth is that we know that it was not at all difficult to meet your German managers or their representatives.

Just think of Rick’s bar in the film Casablanca – set in the north African town, nominally under Vichy France rule, where Americans, Germans and French mixed while Sam played it again.
 
There were plenty of neutral places where meetings could be held. Portugal remained neutral, and smart Estoril, a short train ride from Lisbon, had for decades been a playground for the international rich and well-connected.

The Duke of Windsor – the abdicated Edward VIII - stayed at Cascais just next door, after quitting Paris when the Germans arrived (but staying very much in touch with them.)


[photo] Duke and Duchess of Windsor at Cascais, Portugal, 1940

If you wanted to keep tabs on your factory in Cologne or Russelheim, all you had to do was to stroll on the beach at Estoril or visit its casino, and there you could chat to managers from your German factory with complete impunity.

And there were plenty of other places, for example in neutral Switzerland or Sweden. Not to mention South America.



[photo] Les Trois Rois hotel, Basel, Switzerland where, in July 1941, the governor of the Bank of Sweden lunched with American and German members of the Bank of International Settlements 

#91 Death Camp tattoos were IBM numbers -  Ep 10 Trading with the Nazis

[photo] More than 400,000 prisoners were forcibly tattooed at Auschwitz. The Hoberman Collection

Death Camp tattoos began as IBM-Dehomag punch card numbers
 
Author Edwin Black tells the story of Ethel "Edjya" Katz, a 12-year old Jewish girl, who was among the people locked in a freight truck on a train bound for the extermination camp at Treblinka. The men in the truck managed to force open the ceiling ventilator and pushed Edjya, the only one small enough, out and onto the roof.


[photo] The map shows the borders of the Second Polish Republic at the time of the Nazi-German-and-Soviet invasion of Poland in 1939 with demarcation line between the two invading armies marked in red. Internal boundaries show the administrative divisions of occupied territories imposed by Nazi Germany when the Final Solution was set in motion in 1941

Edjya survived, hid in a forest, met a German boy Herschel, and spent the rest of the war with him, fighting with the resistance. The rest of Edjya’s family were killed. Edjya and Herschel later married and emigrated to the States. They were Edwin Black’s parents.

Black has written a number of understandably angry, popular books and articles detailing IBM’s role during the war in Germany and its occupied territories. What is beyond doubt is that IBM business machines – punch card statistical tabulators originally developed for crunching American census data – were absolutely essential, not only for the German rearmament programme and wartime procurement, but also for organising the Holocaust.
 
It was an enormous statistical challenge. Notoriously each inmate of the concentration and death camps was identified by a five-figure number, tattooed on their arm. Those numbers began as IBM numbers.


[photo] Dehomag DII tabulator

An American legal case in 2001 argued that IBM in America stayed very much in touch with its German subsidiary Dehomag throughout the war. The case was discontinued when IBM agreed to pay into a compensation scheme on condition that all cases were dropped.
 
What Ford and General Motors did, they did through choice

 


[photo] Street round-up (Polish łapanka [waˈpanka]) of random civilians to be deported to Germany for forced labour; Warsaw's Żoliborz district, 1941

Prisoners of war were used as slave labour
 
A detailed study by a team of historians, published by Oxford University Press in 2000, has shown, for all the predictable, corporate denials, that from the summer of 1940, Ford and General Motors used slave labour.

They were mostly prisoners of war. They paid not the workers but the German military authorities. General Motors was also involved in Nazi campaigns to recruit civilian labour in France, Holland, Belgium, Slovakia and Italy and transport it to Germany to work in their factories.

So at General Motor’s Russelheim works, imported labourers worked alongside prisoners, who were often Russian civilians deported and forced to work.The management’s instructions were that labour costs were to ‘be kept as low as possible’ and the working week sometimes stretched to 72 hours.

The factory made one in three of the trucks the German army used in the war. It was making more money than it knew how to spend. Historian Mark Spoerer has shown that Ford and GM were never compelled to accept slave labour. They voluntarily applied for it early in the war when they still retained some of their American management. General Motors was not even put under Nazi oversight until the end of November 1942.

By contrast, historian Charles Cheape’s study of the American company Norton’s Germany subsidiary, DMG, found that it paid its foreign workers at the same rate as its German employees. DMG also tried to protect its Jewish distributor in Belgium. What Ford and GM did, they did through choice.
 
#91 Death Camp tattoos were IBM numbers -  Ep 10 Trading with the Nazis



 
[photo] Schindler's List movie, 1993, directed by Steven Spielberg

This wasn’t like Schindler’s List
 
The Czechoslovak-German businessman Oskar Schindler built a factory in Krakow, Poland (near to the death camps) where he employed 1100 men and women and saved them from the gas chambers. Have you been there?


[photo] Schindler's factory in Krakow, 2011



Survivors say Schindler’s List, the movie, is as accurate a picture of Nazi occupation as they know.


[photo] Ralph Fiennes as Amon Goeth, sadistic Nazi. Spielberg said of Fienne's audition 'I saw sexual evil'



Schindler was employing Polish Jews, who were being systematically exterminated. And that’s completely different from what was happening in factories run by Ford and General Motors.


[photo] Schindler's grave in Jerusalem. The Hebrew inscription reads: 'Righteous Among The Nations'. The German inscription reads: 'The Unforgettable Lifesaver of 1200 Persecuted Jews'



By September 1944 there were 30,000 inmates in 250 camps run by Ford. Many were Russian women. These were people who would not have been sent to the Concentration camps.
View All Episodes
Twitter
Facebook
Website
Spotify
Email
Copyright © 2024 History Cafe, All rights reserved.