Trading with the Nazis

- Episode 05-

‘Hell-bent to supplant our democratic government’

'Hell-bent to supplant our democratic government'
1 February 2024
All History Café links
NEW SERIES Trading with the Enemy
[photo] German troops march along the Champs Elysees, June 1940

A troubling disregard for democracy
 
In 1936 the American ambassador in Berlin William Dodd wrote to the American President Franklyn Roosevelt. There is, wrote Dodd, ‘a clique of US industrialists [that] is hell-bent to bring a fascist state to supplant our democratic government and is working closely with the fascist regime in Germany and Italy. I have had plenty of opportunity in my post in Berlin to witness how close some of our American ruling families are to the Nazi regime.’

Can Dodd possibly have been correct? Or was he getting things out of proportion?

After all the historian Richard Overy has commented that western firms don’t nowadays stop doing business with China (or we might add, for example, Russia or Saudi Arabia) because they have morally repugnant governments. There’s a long, disgraceful and continuing tradition of businesses and their political friends propping tyrants up for the money. Margaret Thatcher and Ronald Reagan were among the worst. Apartheid S.Africa, Pinochet in Chile, General Mohammed Zia ul-Haq in Pakistan, Saddam Hussein and the Khmer Rouge...

But the American Ambassador Dodd had sensed something important. The businesses that were dealing with the Nazis in the 1930s had not only a nose for profits, but also a troubling disregard for democracy, just as they had a dark indifference to morality.

#86 'Hell-bent to supplant our democratic government' -  Ep 5 Trading with the Enemy


[photo] cartoon featuring Raskob, Al Smith, and a flag with dollars on it

The Liberty League for American Millionaires
 
Now, there have been some wild and - so far as any historian has discovered - unsubstantiated claims about this group – that it was planning a military coup against the American government.

It was in fact supposed to be a business lobby above partisan politics. In practice it attempted to sway Americans to vote against President Roosevelt’s second term in 1936. They believed that his New Deal would interfere in their businesses. Which indeed it did, in the interests of the 99% of Americans who were not among the Liberty League millionaires.

The people who’d funded the Liberty League like JP Morgan, Pierre du Pont, JJ Raskob (the GM Chrysler financial chief and builder of the Empire State Building) agreed with the CEO of General Motors (which had invested heavily in Nazi Germany.) He declared in his April 1936 quarterly report that ‘industry must assume the role of enlightened industrial statesmanship… It must aggressively move forward and attune its thinking and its policies toward advancing the interest of the community at large.’

In other words, these men believed that they were not only running their businesses, but also the rest of the world.
 
The League collapsed after the 1936 Presidential Election having been denounced by both Democrats and Republicans as unwarranted interference. So much for being above party politics. Roosevelt was re-elected.
 
 
If there is peace, it will be created by trade [with the enemy] - What?!

[photo] Nazi flag unfurled on the Arc de Triomphe, Paris, June 1940

An American loan to keep the Nazi regime afloat?
 
On 19 April 1938 the man in charge of General Motors in Europe, James Mooney, met with representatives of the Reichsbank and of Herman Göring. Mooney discussed with them the possibility of an enormous American loan – up to $1bn - to keep the Nazi regime afloat (and in fact to pay for its rearmament). What??

Mooney then travelled (on GM expenses) to London to consult representatives of JP Morgan’s bank. He also tried to fix a meeting between the Reichsbank and Joe Kennedy, a well-known - not to say notorious – businessman and former associate of JJ Raskob, [and father of future president JF Kennedy], who was now the US Ambassador in London.

Shuttling on chartered planes between London, Paris, Brussels and Berlin Mooney apparently believed he could persuade the Nazi government to sign a far-reaching agreement – a limit to rearmament, a non-aggression pact and free trade. There would be no Second World War, and all thanks to General Motors.
 


#86 'Hell-bent to supplant our democratic government' -  Ep 5 Trading with the Enemy



[photo] German soldiers enjoy Parisian cafe culture, July 1940

A dinner at the New York Astoria to celebrate the Nazi victory in Paris
 
When GM’s head in Europe James Mooney met with Hitler in March 1940 he deludedly believed he could conjure a cash-for-peace deal. He came away with nothing.

By June 1940  Hitler was strutting around in Paris after defeating the French. On June 26, at the fashionable and expensive Walford Astoria hotel in New York, Mooney met with Sosthenes Behn, the boss of ITT, and other American investors in Germany for a dinner to celebrate the Nazi victory. What???

Three weeks after that, the German embassy in New York was cabling Berlin that a group of businessmen, headed by Mooney and Henry Ford had come up with a plan to put pressure on President Roosevelt to stop supplying arms to Britain and to appoint new American ambassadors both in Berlin and London.

Well, we might just write all these episodes off as harmless fantasies, the delusions of self-promoting crackpots. But these attempts by businessmen to change the course of international events tell us something significant about a state of mind that regards trade as the foundation of world affairs.

If there is peace, it will be created by trade. If there is prosperity, then it will be created by trade. Leave business to run the world and everything will be alright. Nowadays it is misnamed ‘populism.’
 
View All Episodes
Copyright © 2024 History Cafe, All rights reserved.